Departmental Seminar

Seeking Quantum Speedup Through Spin Glasses: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly Abstract

Dr Helmut G. Katzgraber
Department of Physics & Astronomy, Texas A&M University and the Santa Fe Institute, New Mexico
Friday 12 June 2015 11am–12pm
Theoretical Physics seminar room, Le Couteur (Bldg #59), L.3.17

Can quantum computers indeed meet the promise of doing complex calculations faster than classical computers based on transistor technologies? While the holy grail of a programmable universal quantum computer will probably still take decades to reach, one can already begin to answer this question by testing programmable quantum annealing machines that are currently being built. These machines, such as D-Wave Two, use a non-mainstream method known as adiabatic quantum annealing to perform optimization tasks. Very recently, tests performed by different research teams on the D-Wave Two machine using spin glasses as a benchmark have shown that, although the machine indeed appears to tap into quantum effects, it shows no speedup over traditional computing architectures.  Here, after a brief introduction to optimization problems I present reasons why this might be the case: The benchmarks used to test the D-Wave machine are encoded in the restrictive Chimera topology dictated by fabrication constraints of the device. Our finding is that, for the standard benchmark Ising spin glass on the Chimera lattice, its energy landscape is actually rather simple.  This means that searching for a ground state of an Ising spin glass on the Chimera lattice is an easier exercise in optimization for both quantum, as well as vanilla classical optimization methods, i.e., not a measure of sufficient rigor to detect quantum speedup. Our results thus show that a careful design of the hardware architecture and benchmark problems is key when building quantum annealing machines and we present alternative benchmark strategies in the quest for detecting quantum speedup.



  • R. Andrist (Google),
  • F. Hamze (D-Wave),
  • A. Ochoa (Texas A&M),
  • Z. Zhu (Texas A&M)


Dr David Ridout

Updated:  17 August 2017/ Responsible Officer:  Director, RSPE/ Page Contact:  Physics Webmaster